NHL Draft Day Steals and Fails

NHL Draft Day Steals & Fails

No sport does an entry draft quite like the NHL. It's the only sport where teams pick teenagers to transform their franchises. And as you guessed it, that can lead to all kinds of issues and surprises. 

With NHL Draft Day Steals And Fails, I'm chronicling those players who fail to live up to the expectations of where they were drafted. As well as those who surprised us all and outperformed their draft status.

There's a lot of meat on this bone, so keep your eye out for new stories.

NHL Draft Day Steals and Fails Edition 5: Losing The Lottery

Losing the lottery should be catastrophic for a team at the bottom of the NHL standings, right? That wasn't the case for the Colorado Avalanche and Vancouver Canucks in 2017.

NHL Draft Day Steals And Fails Edition 4: Late-Round Steals

No draft pick is a lock to become an impact player at the NHL level. Less so when they're drafted in the late round (6th and 7th). Here are five recent late-round picks who defied the odds. 

NHL Draft Day Steals and Fails Edition 3: How Oilers Failed Yakupov

Think of a draft day bust and Nail Yakupov's name comes to mind. But instead of focusing on how he didn't live up to expectations how did the Edmonton Oilers fail their first overall pick in 2012?

NHL Draft Day Steals and Fails Edition 2: Bolts Break Bias To Take Legend

In the second edition of our ongoing series, we look at how the Tampa Bay Lightning stole the 2011 NHL draft by taking Nikita Kucherov in the second round. 

NHL Draft Day Steals and Fails Edition 1: Islanders Going Based On Need In 2014

The first edition of NHL Draft Day Steals and Fails looks at how the New York Islanders missed a glorious opportunity to add an elite winger, but didn't.

NHL First Overall Picks

Year Player Team
2023 Connor Bedard Chicago Blackhawks
2022 Juraj Slafkovsky Montreal Canadiens
2021 Owen Power Buffalo Sabres
2020 Alexis Lafreniere New York Rangers
2019 New Jersey Devils Jack Hughes
2018 Rasmus Dahlin Buffalo Sabres
2017 New Jersey Devils Nico Hischier
2016 Auston Matthews Toronto Maple Leafs
2015 Connor McDavid Edmonton Oilers
2014 Aaron Ekblad Florida Panthers
2013 Nathan MacKinnon Colorado Avalanche
2012 Nail Yakupov Edmonton Oilers
2011 Ryan Nugent-Hopkins Edmonton Oilers
2010 Taylor Hall Edmonton Oilers
2009 John Tavares New York Islanders
2008 Steven Stamkos Tampa Bay Lightning
2007 Patrick Kane Chicago Blackhawks
2006 Erik Johnson St. Louis Blues
2005 Sidney Crosby Pittsburgh Penguins
2004 Alex Ovechkin Washington Capitals
2003 Marc-Andre Fleury Pittsburgh Penguins
2002 Rick Nash Columbus Blue Jackets
2001 Ilya Kovulchuk Atlanta Thrashers
2000 Rick DiPietro New York Islanders
Back to Top